Pugsley Pizza

Mark Otting 2 months ago

Decided to try Pugsley’s as it had some decent reviews. Let me tell you, the pizza was not only fantastic, Salvatore and his wife are an absolute hoot! So much fun! It’s off the beaten path but worth the walk. Bang the gong when you get there!

Daniel D 5 months ago

Stumbled on this gem late last night and so glad I did! Grabbed a large pepperoni and mushroom pie with garlic knots and some beers. The pizza came out in under 10 mins and was perfectly crispy—exactly how it should be. Great sauce, plenty of cheese, and the knots were incredible. The staff is super welcoming and the place has a total NY vibe with tons of seating. Parking can be tight, but it’s worth the hunt. 10/10 across the board, definitely the place to bring your friends and enjoy a great slice.Thank you once again to the staff and great work in the kitchen!! 👏🏼

Mike Reviewed It! 7 months ago

Really glad Bae found this spot for our pizza fix after our nearby botanical garden visit. Can’t believe I haven’t come here before. It is off the beaten path on a side street so there was no chance of randomly passing by and spotting while in the area. Luckily they have their own parking lot which is surprising and much appreciated so parking was a breeze. The shop is family run and I love that for them. The slices are really, really good. You have to try the home made hot oil/ sauce. The slices were so good I had to take two home for later. This is definitely the to go pizza shop when in the area. The inside restaurant is very eclectic. Kinda dirty looking with worn out cushioned benches but perhaps that’s the charm.

James Wood 7 months ago

Pugsley Pizza is a true hidden gem in the Bronx. The food is excellent, especially the pizza, and everything comes out fresh and exactly how you want it. They’re more than happy to customize your order, which makes the experience even better. Sal behind the counter is a big part of what makes this place special. He’s incredibly friendly, provides great service, and really puts on a show. Whether he’s joking around with customers or breaking out the saxophone, he brings a fun energy that makes the visit memorable. The Philly cheesesteak is also outstanding and definitely worth trying. The spot is close to the Bronx Zoo, making it a great stop before or after a visit. It can get busy, but that just tells you how good it is. If you’re in the area, this place is absolutely worth checking out.

Michael Vaccari 8 months ago

A real college greasy spoon kind of place. The 1st thing you see on entering is a walnut dining room table an chairs... right out of grandma's house. You order your pizza, then sit at a cozy booth surrounded by grafitti on the walls. Signatures and epithets from customers in years gone by. When your order is ready, the pier man strikes a large gong! The food was great, and the place was a fun visit!